Aloeswood Resin/A Comparison of Minorien Kyara Ryugen, Shoyeido Ga-Ho and Baieido Koh En

It’s been mentioned a lot here and I generally agree that really high quality aloeswood incense has a steep learning curve. This idea was brought a little closer in comparing the three sticks in the subject line. All three of these incenses use very high quality wood, although if the latter two do not have kyara level wood, they certainly have the next best thing. Sticks like Minorien’s aloeswood, not to mention the various qualities in Shoyeido’s aloeswood chips bring home just how obviously resinated a wood can be. Whether you’d describe it as tarry or turpentine like, it seems to me all the glory of a wood can be found in this element, this conglomeration of aged aromatics.

Yet it’s not always that obvious and in particular I picked out three sticks by three different companies I’ve been using lately that actually have the same sort of element. In none of these did I recognize just how quality the wood was right away. With Ga-Ho I first noticed the dill or cumin notes that bring out the dryness. Second I noticed the floral perfume that balances it. Only after a third or fourth stick did the powerful resin of the wood really make itself known, but when it did this stick opened up like a lotus flower and my impression of it went up.

This is even more obscure with Baieido’s Koh En. Like most of their premium aloeswoods, the sticks are thin and the aroma is mellow and if these sticks use any spices or extra ingredients other than binder, I can imagine the purpose is to bring out the wood alone. But such a stick also fooled me into ignoring the resin quality at first. I think there’s a pretty big difference between Baieido and Shoyeido aloeswood, the latter seems robust and intense, while the former seems to capture the sublimity better, but it’s a quality so fleeting and faint it can be hard to pick up. Because with higher level Baieido aloeswood like Hakusui, the general nature of the resin, while just as conglomerated and fierce as any other good wood, actually seems more floral and/or spicy in quality and less resinous in a tarry sense. And with Koh En you get those qualities more up front. At first it’s hard to differentiate it from the lower ends in the same line, but the more I thought about what makes Koh En different, the more I realized it was the same level of resin. It speaks to a very long learning curve.

Kyara Ryugen, of course, really does up the resin element and at levels like this the whole glory of what makes aloeswood special comes out. Both Koh En and Ga-Ho are great at evoking old memories, but it’s a different level with Ryugen. Koh En definitely has complexity in terms of listening to the wood and Ga-Ho is complex among all its facets, but the quality of Ryugen is high enough to do what Koh En does while making it seem like it’s as multi-faceted as Ga-Ho, without much need for anything but the wood. Ryugen can start, woody, dry and brash like the rest of the Minorien line, but almost instantly the wood’s resin starts to emit spirals of inherent floral behavior, but on a level that is so intense that the incense continually reminds you this character comes from the kyara, at least in part. And like Koh En, the resin feel never quite gets tarry, on the contrary Ryugen has an almost powdery sweet like quality that is almost tropically exotic, so exotic that it resonates with watery, emotional qualities and continually drives one to passionate responses.



  1. Anonymous said,

    May 19, 2008 at 11:31 pm

    I believe all this shortage of woods is hype because I feel that a Japanese incense boom in the states is going to be created like the cigar thing in the 90’s. I think this is tactics to make it more luxurious and shi shi to wealthy Americans. Mark my words a Japanese incense boom is coming in the states within the next two years. These are pre- preparation tactics for up coming pricing scams. Japanese incense is going to be pushed on the wine,food and luxury item higher income people. There is a real untapped market for this.The same thing done with wine,food and cigars will be done which may ruin the whole of Japanese incense because of a high demand created by greedy vultures. I speak from experience, I know how people attempt marketing at the wealthy in order to make a buck with products that are deemed elite. This is going to be done, it is already in the works. The public just hasn’t seen it yet. We are just a head of the the promo game that is coming.It should be interesting how Japanese incense is received by the phonies in this country. That is who it will be pushed toward. I should know ,I reside in Los Angeles where the phonies will purchase anything promoted as upscale and elite. This is sad but true. Friends stock up the good stuff before the boom!!! I don’t want to seem negative or paranoid but I know what I am talking about and have been ahead of the so called upscale trends for decades.This is going to be one of the latest. Just look at whats happening in Europe lately with Japanese incense. This is all by design and is and has been thought out. Japanese incense will be made pop and it will ruin the supply of great woods. It may even be so over exposed it becomes cheesey like what happened to cigars, because of over exposure by the greedy looking to just cash in on a trend.I hope for the best and send prayers for the supply to last for the sake of true appreciation of Japanese incense. Thank You Mike………Kohdude

  2. Mike said,

    May 19, 2008 at 7:22 am

    Very true on the Baieido aloeswoods. Sometimes I think you may need close to perfect conditions for those. I’ve been working with Koh En quite a bit, but it’s still not something I’d put in my top 10, but I’m thinking the sublimity of the scent might win out in the end.

  3. Ross said,

    May 17, 2008 at 11:18 pm

    I am having to “gut it out” til next paycheck for these. I especialy have a very strong desire to stock up on the Baieido
    premium aloeswoods. I remember from my sampler pack of them that they really are the essence of subtle, its about the wood, hold the spice and no oil please.
    I have heard that many of the companies are waiting for the next “turning of the screws” from CITES. Which will make it harder for them to get the raw materials, so prices go up.
    But besides all that, some days ya just want the quality resins, straight up!

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: