Lung Ta / Drib Poi, Ribo Sang Chhoe, White Sur, Red Sur

Lung Ta, based on the Portuguese language on the rolls and the use of Brazilian Juniper, appears to be something of a Tibetan-Brazilian cooperative, but it’s not particularly clear if they’re mostly distributor or creative partner. Because even for Tibetan (and Bhutanese and Nepali…) incense these four incenses are quite unusual, with a base of ingredients that imparts certain qualities to all their incenses. These main ingredients include the aforementioned Brazilian juniper, sassafras, aromatic calamus, Indian cloves, cardamom and cinnamon. This base, while having some aspects in common with the general (Tibetan) style, actually moves in an almost food-like direction. The underlying aroma imparts hints of spice cookies and oatmeal cereal with the juniper basically buried and all the spices up front and read to interact with the finishing touches.

Strangely enough some of the specific incense ingredients seem to build upon this base and add other ingredients unusual for incense. For example, Riwo Sang Chhoe uses fruits, cereals, medicinal substances and mineral dust such as gold, silver and coppper. Some of these ingredients are more likely to be linked to the incenses’ mystical properties than to what they do aromatically, but what’s strange is that some of what I listed can really be detected. The base as above almost has lactic hints to it and the results almost seem like combinations of incense and cereals. It really sets this line apart from other Tibetan-style incenses and the blends tend to actually smoothe out some of the harsh notes you tend to find in some multi-herbal recipes.

From the look of it, Drib Poi has seven natural ingredients, so must be considered the simplest incense of the four here, but it’s also the one I like the most. I’m curious about the seventh ingredient as it imparts a green color the other three incenses don’t have, and not only that but a spicy, exotic tinge that reminds me of a spicy Thai green curry. The milkiness of the whole line definitely compliments the herbal nature and there’s a slighty sour, tangy quality that’s quite alluring. This is definitely a unique incense for the style, it made me wonder what it’d be like with a little agarwood.

Ribo Sang Chhoe is rather different although the spice cookie base stil remains and the above mentioned ingredients either overlap or were added. I laughed when I read in the description that this is “as if we were offering a complete meal that offers joy and delight.” Be sure not to take a bite of the stick after this description and the incense’s aroma as this is less an entree and more a confectionary. I got hints of cocoa butter, graham crackers and orange spice here with a stronger background wood presence that gives it a slight dryness and ties it roughly together with White Sur. While this still has a bit of tangyness to it, the aftereffects kind of fade into the citrus and spice.

 White Sur opens up the ingredient list to over 200 entries. This sort of thing makes me think of centuries of experimentation in order to realize White Sur is what the creators wanted. The incense itself doesn’t necessarily set itself apart from the rest of the line by way of the implied complexity, in fact White Sur isn’t terribly far off from Ribo Sang Chhoe, but the many ingredients do start to impress themselves upon you with use. The incense starts out with an almost sweetgrass like aroma but once that top note starts to fade, you’re left not only with the base as already described but a lot of extras playing with it. It might be close to what Drib Poi would be like without the green herbal hints, just concentrating on the cereal aspects. The cardamom in particular seems to be the most out front.

Red Sur might be the incense of the four most reminiscent of what you may already have experienced with Tibetan incense, its red color moves it closer to a number of monastery incenses that end up with a slight berry aroma. With the food-like qualities of this line, Red Sur kind of reminds me of a tart raspberry or strawberry yogurt, or better yet like a bowl of strawberry Cheerios. The scent seems to be a bit tarter than the other three because of it and as such sets it apart a bit more, but at the same time it seems to have a drier finish, one that tends to move one’s attention from the base a little more. There still is a hint of cereal and spice in the background but here its the most muted in the line.

I didn’t imagine when sampling these things to be as impressed with the brand’s uniqueness as I was, and I could tell that my understanding of the complexity of these incenses increased with use, meaning there’s something of a learning curve with these. While they seem to use a lot of more common ingredients, it seems the creators have found a way to blend food and minerals to actually bring out qualities like that in an aroma, which couldn’t have been easy (but please don’t go trying to light your curry or yogurt on fire). And not only that but at $5 a roll they’re very affordable and there’s also a density and earthiness to the sticks that seem to make them burn maybe a little longer than other, drier Tibetan sticks. Definitely a stop for the olfactory explorer.


  1. September 2, 2010 at 1:55 pm

    […] Lung Ta / Drib Poi – I am returning to this Tibetan stick fairly often even though in doing so I keep sampling the rest of the line and wonder why I like this one so much more. I think it must be the curry-ish spice to it which seems missing in the others, a green-ish , exotic tinge that brings out the ingredient complexity. […]

  2. Claire said,

    February 17, 2009 at 10:57 am

    I have to agree that the one I tried had a different character each time I went back to it but sadly it just didn’t want to grow on me. I guess I still havequite Western tastes in incense. It’s a personal taste thing though, so hopefully the next person in the Incense Trading Circle will be delighted to receive my supply.

  3. Claire said,

    February 14, 2009 at 6:42 am

    Riwo Sang Chhoe (Tibetan Incense) – Lung Ta)

    Not as easy to light as some – it took me 3 attempts.

    I didn’t like this the first time that I tried it (finding it harsh and bitter) and left it in the cupboard, but now that I have tried several other incenses and honed my tastes a bit more, I thought it was time to give it another try before adding it to the box for the Incense Trading circle.

    There is definitely more than one thing going on here so it is more complex than I first realised.

    As the smoke wafted away from me, I was immediately hit by a citrus washing up liquid aroma (even though the ingredients list doesn’t specifically include anything citrus, although it may be what was described as “fruits”). This was quickly replaced, bar the occasional waft, by a strong alpine herbal aroma (similar to that found in several of the incenses in the Gift Box by The Dhoop Factory). It wasn’t as strong as the Dhoop Factory ones but for me personally that was better as it tempted a headache much less.

    The problem for me was when the smoke wafted towards me. It was that same harsh, bitter aroma that I remembered from when I first tested it. It made my eyes sting and irritated my nose. It was a different harshness though to that produced by cheap filler woods. Looking at the ingredients list I would attribute it to the milk as the aroma was comparable to milk being left to continue burning to the bottom of a pan – the gold, silver and copper presumably giving the smell of the metal of the pan itself burning. I think I could detect the cereal content too as there was a smell that I would imagine would be produced if cereal was thrown on an open fire.

    So all in all, I was able to detect all of the ingredients listed (but unfortunately not the cocoa butter and spice that Mike’s keener nose picked up) – in a pleasant way if you can control the smoke to travel away from you (with a fan perhaps), but too harsh on the nose if the smoke comes towards you.

    • Mike said,

      February 17, 2009 at 10:13 am

      I really like this line, they all seem to improve with more use and are very complex incenses. There are times where they strike me as harsh, but just as many times they strike me as uncommonly sublime and interesting. At their price range they really can’t be beat for Tibetan incenses. You’re absolutely right it might be the milk or whatever it is they use, I think they even have bits of metal in the incenses which could account for those aromas as well.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: