Ross did a short review of Seikado’s Jinkoh Gohitsu in 2010, and my memory around the time is it was the only “Five Brushstrokes” aloeswood on the market and so I remember stumbling across the Meiko Gohitsu on the Japan Incense website and getting somewhat confused in that I think I asked for a sample but managed to request the one I already knew instead of the one I didn’t and eventually just ordered boxes of both of them. I would say that if I didn’t find the Hitori Shizuka incenses a particularly successful take on more modern leaning aloeswood incenses, I would say that it may be closer to the opposite with these two.
The Meiko Gohitsu is a green colored stick with a really interesting and somewhat fresh blend of aloeswood and spices, and likely a bit of sandalwood too. It’s a really lovely and elegant scent with some herbal content that tends to move this away from most scents you’d be familiar with. The description says that there are a blend of aloeswoods, but what you get is something more of a midline scent overall, a bit woody and maybe a hint of resin, although the latter seems to be a bit subsumed in whatever herbs and spices it is mixed with. I am also not sure if the point of the Five Brushtrokes line is to give the scent something of an India Ink profile but there’s some element of this scent that is also reminiscent of the incense or two I have tried with that in mind. It all adds up to something fresh and different and does have enough of a legit aloeswood scent to be kind of impressive at such a decent price. I am a big fan of incenses that take lateral steps as they are refreshing to the palate so this one is definitely recommended.
Jinkoh Gohitsu appears to be a slight step up and has a much brasher aloeswood presence than the Meiko. The sort of green herbal nature of the Meiko is gone, although there’s no move at all on the sort of aromatic ink-like quality it had. So it’s unquestionably a much woodier incense but still has the modern profile and cool artistic approach. I would guess this too has a touch of sandalwood to help contour the woodiness of it and it has a really vibrant freshness. While I’m not sure the aloeswood mix in this supersedes the Meiko in any appreciable way quality wise, I think it’s definitely a woodier incense. Which means these are really two different incenses rather than being grades. Honestly I’m not even sure which one I’d recommend first simply because the herbs and spices in the Meiko are so unique that it feels a bit more original than the Jinkoh, while the Jinkoh is still likely to appeal to those who like their scents woodier. For the price range I think both of these are winners.
You must be logged in to post a comment.